It may be the way a slice fresh from the oven immediately lifts people’s spirits. Perhaps it’s the aroma of melting cheese and blissfully blistered crust. Or, maybe it’s just the plain old fact that everybody, from your five-year-old nephew, your food-obsessed pal who judges olive oil for sport, enjoys pizza.
But here’s the twist: Not every pizza is created equal. And neither are all parties. So if you’re going to bring your people together — to celebrate, reconnect, or simply enjoy yourselves — why not do it right?
At Anthony’s, pizza isn’t just food. It’s the centerpiece. A conversation starter. The heart of the party. And once you try it, you’ll wonder why you ever bought from somewhere else.
Legendary Flavor That Brings Everyone Together
Coal-fired flavor isn’t just a taste, it’s a whole mood at Anthony’s. Our signature ovens bring that perfectly crisp, golden brown crust you can’t fake, delivering an old-world meets new-school flavor that’s instantly unforgettable. One bite, and you’re hooked.
But let’s talk ingredients. From hand-stretched dough to our tangy tomato sauce and premium toppings, each dish at Anthony’s is made fresh to order. It’s the kind of quality that brings everyone to the table: the foodie, the picky eater, the “just one slice” guest who ends up going back for thirds.
Whether you’re in the mood for something timeless or ready to try something bold, we have the flavor lineup to match. From coal-fired wings and artisan sandwiches to fresh pastas and loaded salads, there’s something for every craving and every kind of party.
A Menu Built for Sharing
The best memories are made when there’s food on the table and stories in the air. And at Anthony’s, every meal is made to bring people together.
Start with our signature Maria’s meatballs: hand-rolled, sauce-dipped, and slow-simmered in Italian plum tomato sauce with hand-grated Pecorino Romano. Or go meat-free and try the fan-favorite Eggplant Marino: thinly sliced eggplant caramelized at the edges, baked to perfection, and served with fresh basil and sauce.
Looking to feed a crowd? Our shareable pasta trays and party-sized salads make it easy. Vegetarian? Covered. Craving heat? Try a Mike’s Hot Honey pizza or spicy wings. Picky eater? There’s always a Margherita.
Bottom line? Nobody leaves hungry, and everyone leaves talking about it.
Stress-Free Planning with Catering & Pickup Options
Our catering service is designed for actual people who are busy hosts who want to impress without stressing. You can order online with just a few clicks, pick from curated party packages, or mix and match your favorites à la carte.
Whether it’s a party size of 5 or 50, we’ve got you covered.
Delivery? Check.
Pickup? Check.
Custom orders according to dietary restrictions or party theme? Check. Check. Check.
And to top it all off, our catering staff is just a phone call away should you require assistance with crafting a menu that strikes all the right chords. It’s hospitality combined with hustle, so you can have fun at your party for once.
Fan-Favorite Signature Pizzas That Steal the Show
Forget the basic cheese or pepperoni, we are here to turn every pizza night into an event.
- Paulie’s Pie: Homemade baby meatballs, with Italian sausage, hot or sweet peppers, and ricotta cheese.
- Square Margherita: Rustic, homey, with that coal-fired crunch that gives the classic its twist with Italian plum tomato sauce.
- Mike’s Hot Honey®: Sweet heat and completely addictive.
- Meatball & Ricotta Pizza: Decadent, comforting, and the food equivalent of a hug, featuring creamy dollops of ricotta cheese
- 10″ Cheese Pizza + Beverage: Indulge in a cheese-filled journey with this chunky cheese pizza with Mozzarella, our Italian plum tomato sauce, and hand-grated Romano.
Each pizza is designed to leave an impression. A taste experience that continues the conversation (even when lips are empty).
It’s Not a Party Without Dessert
A real pizza party doesn’t conclude with the final crust. It ends on a sweet note.
At Anthony’s, dessert is part of the celebration and not an afterthought: crunchy, creamy mini cannolis that snap when you bite; rich, New York-style cheesecake that melts right in every forkful; and a three-layer chocolate mousse cake so indulgent it might just steal the spotlight from the pizza.
They’re simple to serve, simple to love, and the best way to ensure your party ends with a bang, not a whimper. Whether you’re hosting at home, at the office, or in the field after a big win, our desserts wrap your meal in pure joy.
Why Anthony’s Sets the Standard
Anthony’s isn’t just a place. It’s an attitude.
It’s the cozy greeting when you walk in. The commotion in the kitchen. The scent that grabs your attention before your eyes even hit the menu.
It’s old-world craftsmanship meets modern convenience — reliable without compromise. Whether you’re dining in, carrying out, or catering a crowd, every dish is made fresh, fast, and full of flavor. From our coal-fired crust to our housemade sauces and hand-cut toppings, you taste the care in every bite.
And with options for every kind of eater, classic, spicy, vegetarian, gluten-sensitive, we make sure no one at your party is left out. Anthony’s doesn’t just show up for pizza night. We show up for game days, birthdays, first dates, graduations, and random Tuesdays. Great food. Great people. Legendary parties. That’s the Anthony’s way.
Craving some coal-fired goodness? Drop by your nearest Anthony’s outlet now.
